South Australia has had it for years. Europeans get discounts off their beer for taking bottles back. Is it that hard? This is a response to a pro-forma letter I send to the last state government about creating a container deposit scheme for Victoria. The campaign is STILL going. Here is a link to the campaign website.
http://mps.vic.greens.org.au/10cdeposit
Dear Correspondent
PROPOSAL FOR DEPOSITS ON DISPOSABLE DRINK CONTAINERS
Thank you for your recent email to the Premier, advocating the
introduction of container deposits in Victoria to increase recycling. I
am replying on the Premier’s behalf.
While the Victorian Government is not in favour of container deposits,
for the reasons outlined below, it is important to note that it did not
prevent debate on the Greens’ bill. The Constitution Act 1975 requires
that legislation which might require funds to be drawn from consolidated
revenue must originate from the lower house. The Greens’ proposed scheme
had the potential to impose a cost on government, and so the Clerk of
the Legislative Assembly considered the bill a revenue bill, and it was
therefore not possible for the Legislative Assembly to debate it.
South Australia is the only State that has container deposits for some
disposable beverage containers, as well as running kerbside collections
for all recyclable materials as we have in Victoria. South Australian
and Victorian recycling data suggests that both recycle at similar rates
for the items covered by container deposits. However, South Australians
pay significantly more for recycling services, as they actually run two
collection systems.
Beverage containers make up a relatively small proportion of all waste
and should not be given undue focus. A more comprehensive approach to
waste will see recovery of significant quantities of resources across
the entire waste spectrum and the reduction of all types of litter.
Because comprehensive waste reduction is our aim in Victoria, we provide
kerbside collection services throughout the State for materials such as
glass, paper, aluminium, steel and most plastic containers. These
services are augmented by recycling programs in public places,
specialist services for smaller volume wastes such as batteries and
electronic goods, and specific programs to reduce commercial and
industrial wastes. We are also working to increase the range of
materials for which recycling services are provided, and to influence
manufacturers so that they consider using recycled and recyclable
materials in their products.
The Victorian Government’s Towards Zero Waste plan sets a target of
reducing all waste generated by 12 per cent and increasing the overall
recycling rate to 75 per cent by 2014. You can find information about
Towards Zero Waste and our progress towards these targets at the
Sustainability Victoria website
www.sustainability.vic.gov.au.
Increasing recycling is an important means of reducing the quantities of
waste reaching Victoria’s landfills, thereby reducing the environmental
impacts both of sourcing raw materials and disposing of waste. The
Victorian Government considers it is essential to achieve these waste
reductions as effectively and efficiently as we can.
Thank you again for writing to the Premier about your views.
Yours sincerely
DAN O'BRIEN
Chief of Staff